Followers

Total Pageviews

Thursday, February 23, 2023

Wonderland Burlesque's Let's Go To The Movies: That Girl! Edition Part III

Wonderland Burlesque's 
Let's Go To The Movies
That Girl! Edition Part III

Who's that girl? Well, I'll tell you who...

This week's Let's All Go To The Movies continues to be all about 'that girl'. You know the one! 

The one whose essence can instantly be captured with one or two words before attaching the word 'girl'. Sure, she's a full-blooded woman (in most cases), but let's keep it young and vital and grant her 'girl' status anyway. 

What makes her tick? And what sells tickets? 

Well, we've got a lot of girls waiting in queue, so... 

Let's pop some corn, grab a seat on the aisle and take a peek at this week's selection of cinematic magic.

Bad Girl
(1931)
"A novel of New York life."

(She believes that every guy is on the make. He believes that women are only interested in money and having a good time. When they meet, its a match made in heaven. But then, one evening, he leaves her standing in the rain, so she tracks him down to his apartment where the two end up cuddling and cooing like lovebirds all night. When morning comes, reality intrudes. What will she tell her brother? He tells her to tell him she's getting married! And so she does... but will he show up for the big day?)

"You've read Viña Delmar's emotional expose'. Now see..."

(Adapted from the 1928 novel by Viña Delmar and the 1930 play by Delmar and Brian Marlowe.
This romantic drama was directed by Frank Borzage and stars Sally Eilers, James Dunn, and Minna Gombell.)
.

(Getting this one past the Hays Office proved quite the task. A November 16, 1928, memo from the Hays Office put a damper on the whole production, stating: "Bad Girl might be produced as a sex hygiene picture called Motherhood. It is simply the story of girl who is 'bad' for one night, marries the boy the next day, and then has a baby." The memo described the novel as a "nauseating story of doctors, illnesses, etc." and as "cheap and shoddy writing about cheap and shoddy people.")

(That didn't stop the studios from lining up to take a shot at it. Pathé, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Paramount Pictures, Universal Pictures, and Columbia Pictures all threw their hats in the ring, but got scared off by the censors. Only Fox came up with a treatment that passed muster by avoiding the most scandalous aspects of the story.)

(Despite winning the war, Fox executives didn't think for a moment that the film possessed any commercial appeal. At first, Borzage refused to direct it. However, after pressuring him, Borzage begrudgingly accepted the assignment, figuring he had nothing to lose since his contract was about to expire and wasn't expected to be renewed.) 


(Borzage originally wanted Spencer Tracy to play the lead role, but Fox refused. They further tied his hands by giving him a skinny budget and a couple of unproven actors for the leads. But, rather than be discourage, Borzage seized it as an opportunity to do things his way. Dunn, an experienced stage actor, made his screen debut, while Eilers, who had previously appeared in Buster Keaton films as an ingénue and was known for using "the filthiest language in Hollywood," was cast as the titular girl.) 

(The end result? A surprise box office hit.)

(The film made stars out of the then-unknown Eilers and Dunn. It was also nominated for three Academy Awards, including Best Picture, and won for Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay. Frank Borzage became the first person to win a second Best Director Academy Award.)

--- ---

Small Town Girl 
(1936)

(A small town girl works at the family's grocery store and finds her life dull and repetitious. One night she meets a young, handsome, rich boy, who asks her for directions while drunk. Taking a liking to her, he proceeds to take her out for a night on the town. Having a great time, he then asks the girl to marry him - that very night! After hesitating, she thinks about her boring existence and consents. The next morning, now sober, the young man regrets what he's done and wants the marriage ended immediately. However, his parents, concerned about appearances, think differently and insist the young couple remain together for six months before divorcing. The rich boy comes to resent the small town girl for standing in the way of him and his fiancée Priscilla, but the small town girl prays that he'll have a change of heart and stay with her forever.)

(Based on a novel by Ben Ames Williams, this romantic comedy was directed by William A. Wellman and stars Janet Gaynor, Robert Taylor, and James Stewart - with a  supporting cast which includes Binnie Barnes, Andy Devine, Lewis Stone and Edgar Kennedy.


(MGM had originally slated this as a vehicle for Jean Harlow. However, Janet Gaynor, who had been 20th Century Fox's most important star during the late silent and early talkie periods, became available. You see, by 1936, Gaynor's status at Fox had been eclipsed by none other than Shirley Temple. So Gaynor and Fox executives were only too happy for her to take advantage of this opportunity to work at MGM in what was promised to be a first-class production, particularly since she would be cast opposite MGM's hottest young leading man, Robert Taylor.)


 (Director William Wellman came on board late in the game. He had made a career doing both  comedies and action films, but his comedy style proved too rough-and-tumble for Gaynor, and the two clashed repeatedly during filming. In fact, Wellman was so unhappy he asked to be removed from the picture; a request MGM denied.)

 (Later that same year, Wellman went to work for David O. Selznick on a pet project of his, A Star Is Born. Selznick thought Gaynor would be perfect for the lead, and Wellman? Well, despite his earlier issues working with Gaynor, he agreed wholeheartedly with Selznick's choice and their second collaboration turned out to be a  much happier experience for both star and director.)




--- ---

Jungle Girl
(1941)

(Driven from civilization by the criminal activities of his twin brother, a doctor, with his infant daughter in tow, settles in the African jungle. But the Masamba tribes owns vast diamond mines attracting the attention of crooks the world over.)


(Based on the 1932 novel Jungle Girl by Edgar Rice Burroughs, this 15-chapter Republic serial was directed by William Witney and John English and stars Frances Gifford.)


(Though officially based on Edgar Rice Burroughs' Jungle Girl, the serial bore almost no resemblance to the novel, which is about an Asian princess, not a white woman. Even the lead character, Nyoka, was an invention of the studio.)


(This was the first sound serial to have a female lead.)


\


--- ---

Pin Up Girl
(1944)

 (A local girl is the toast of  the Missouri military canteen and has become 'engaged' to just about every serviceman she's signed her  photo for. But now she's leaving her home state behind, off to join the USO. Once in New York, she meets the man of her dreams; a real naval hero. Soon her musical ambitions invite all sorts of hilarious complications, begging the question... will true love win out?)


(Based on a short story titled Imagine Us! by Libbie Block, this Technicolor musical romantic comedy was directed by H. Bruce Humberstone and stars Betty Grable, John Harvey, Martha Raye, and Joe E. Brown.)


(Originally designed as a vehicle for Linda Darnell and Don Ameche, it was decided that the movie would be more popular made as a musical, thereby making it a natural fit for  Betty Grable. The film was then written to capitalized on Grable's iconic pin-up status during World War II, going so far as to use her most popular pin-up photo, which had been of value to GI morale during the war, in the movie.)


(Betty Grable was seven months pregnant when this musical was completed. That famous picture of Betty in a swimsuit taken from the back with her looking over her shoulder was posed that way because her pregnancy, which was well-advanced and showed. The powers that be felt that a pregnant Grable? Not much of a pinup.)


(As part of the finale, Grable leads a WAC drill team in some intricate maneuvers. The producers decided to use a real WAC drill team, rather than actresses for this sequence since they were already familiar with the routines.)

Betty Grable

--- ---

Small Town Girl
(1953)

(A judge's daughter is duty bound to keep an eye on a dashing playboy after he's sentenced to 30 days in jail for speeding through a small town. Turns out the playboy is head over heels in love with a big Broadway star. He manages to persuades the judge's daughter to let him go to New York City for one night, so that he can visit the star on her birthday. Once he returns to finish out his sentence, he then goes on the town with the judge's daughter and she falls in love with him. However, the local doctor wants his son to marry the judge's daughter, setting in motion all sorts of colorful hijinks.)


(This MGM musical was directed by László Kardos and stars Jane Powell, Farley Granger, and Ann Miller. The legendary Busby Berkeley choreographed several of the dance numbers and features song performances by Nat King Cole. One of its tunes, My Flaming Heart, was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Original Song.)

(Ricardo Montalban, Van Johnson, Peter Lawford, and Dean Miller were at one time considered for the lead in this film. Jane Powell was actually pregnant throughout the shoot. She later recalled, "I was sick all the time and don't remember much about it." Contry singer Hank Williams was set to make his acting debut in this film, playing the part of a small-town sheriff. However, he died shortly before filming began.)


(The film contains one of Ann Miller's most memorable musical numbers from the MGM era, I've Gotta Hear That Beat. The brainchild of master showman Busby Berkeley, the highly inventive sequence placed Miller amidst a sea of disembodied musical instruments that appear to be playing themselves through cut-outs in the floor. While the number has long been considered a feast for the eyes, few are aware that Berkeley complemented the visual experience in audio terms too, as every time Miller passes a new section of the orchestra, that particular instrument takes the lead on the song.)

(For the reprise of Take Me to Broadway, Bobby Van performs an extended dance sequence in which he jumps continuously for nearly five minutes. At first glance, it appears that he accomplishes the entire routine in one take. However, the dance was so tiring that it was cut into five segments, so that he could rest. The cuts are covered by changes in camera angles and placement. In Bobby Van's hopping/dance sequence, he jumps a whopping 460 times!)


(The film did poorly at the box office, resulting in a loss of $287,000 for MGM according to studio records.)

--- ---

College Girl
(1960)

(In India, girls from the moment of their birth are viewed as a liability by their parents. And if your father is a judge who is both illiterate and orthodox, you are expected to honor the status quo. But not so for one young woman; she refuses to bow down and wishes to take her rightful place in society; she has dreams of becoming a doctor. When her father stands in her way, she turns to a close friend of his who just happens to be a doctor. With the man's help, she overcomes her father's objections and makes her way through a number of difficult situations which would discourage a lesser light - but not this young woman.)
 
(This black-and-white family drama was directed by T. Prakash Rao and stars Shammi Kapoor, Vyjayanthimala, Om Prakash, Tabassum, Nana Palsikar, Raj Mehra, Purnima, Randhir, Achala Sachdev, Leela Mishra, and Mohan Choti.)

(Actress Vyjayanthimala, who played the titular role, recalled, in conjunction with a tribute to actor Shammi Kapoor, that "whilst working in College Girl, he adopted a peculiar way of walking on his toes, which he effectively created himself.")

--- ---

Black Girl
(1966)
AKA: La noire de
 
(Searching for a better life, a young Senegalese woman takes a job as a governess for a French family, but soon finds her duties reduced to those of a maid. Mistreated and made constantly aware of her race by her employers, she finds herself  increasingly disillusioned, isolated and given to fits of despair.)


(This French-Senegalese drama was written and directed by Ousmane Sembène and stars Mbissine Thérèse Diop. Its original French title is La noire de. It is believed to be the first feature film made by a black African in sub-Saharan Africa.)


(Critics in the US and Europe did not initially recognize Black Girl's lasting power, dismissing it as melodramatic. However, once critics revisited the film after its restoration in 2016, they acknowledged it's cultural significance and found more to praise.)




--- ---

Gypsy Girl
(1966)
AKA: Sky West And Crooked
"Haley Mills - as lovable as in Tiger Bay, as vivacious as in Parent Trap, unforgettable now as a young girl who falls desperately in love for the first time..."

(After the death of a childhood friend ten years earlier and much to the consternation of the locals, a traumatized, lonely, emotionally-challenged teen girl finds solace in burying dead animals found on the side of the road or in the woods. Her alcoholic mother continues to make things worse by treating her as a child even though she stands on the brink of womanhood. When the girl convinces the local children to follow her lead and the town's graveyard fills with tiny tombstones, the townsfolk demand that something be done, demanding that the girl be institutionalized. But the local Reverend understands the girl's motivation and tries to calm the locals, declaring her harmless. Ultimately, the girl finds herself in real danger - and that is when a young man, a member of a nearby gypsy encampment, comes to her rescue.)

"There is a wonderful moment in every girl's life when she takes her first step as a woman."

(This romantic drama which stars Hayley Mills, was directed by her father, Sir John Mills, and was co-written by her mother, Mary Hayley Bell. It is the only film John Mills ever directed.)


(Released as Sky West And Crooked in the UK, the title is derived from a West Country term for someone who is 'not quite right in the head'.)



(This movie was made under the working title, Bats with Baby Faces, based on a line from a T.S. Eliot poem. However,  Mills was persuaded to change it in order to prevent people from thinking it was a Hammer horror movie about vampires. Many critics found the new title, Sky West And Crooked, incomprehensible, even though it was explained in the film.)


(In her memoir, Hayley Mills revealed that she was struggling with bulimia throughout the production of this film.)


--- ---

College Girl
(1978)

(A man  who works at a jewelry shop lives happily with his wife and their two daughters, both whom attend college. It is their father's wish that they receive a good education. One of the daughters has fallen in love with one of her colleagues, while the other runs with a group wealthy girls at the college, enjoying the thrill of their fast-paced, wild lifestyle. When a man comes into the jewelry shop trying to sell fake jewels, the father reports him to the police. This makes the man very angry and he decides to get his revenge, making the father a target. First the man seduces and molests the daughter who is living the high life. He then frames the father for theft, which renders the family homeless. As the other daughter struggles to keep the family afloat, her boyfriend, not understanding where all her time is being spent, accuses her of being unfaithful - which is how they discover that her sister is now involved with a gang of smugglers.)


This Hindi romantic crime thriller is a remake of 1976's Lipstick which starred Margauxl Hemingway, Chris Sarandon and Anne Bancroft. Directed by S. D. Narang, it stars Sachin, Bindiya Goswami, Rita Bhaduri, Bhagwan, Paintal, and Shreeram Lagoo.


(The soundtrack features a number of 'borrowed' tunes. The song Everybody Dance With Me contains samples from In Da Gada Vida by Iron Butterfly and The Troggs' s Wild Thing, while the song I Love You contains a prelude and vocals lifted from Donna Summer's 1977 hit, I Feel Love.)

--- ---

Working Girl
(1988)

A secretary comes up with a great idea which is stolen by her boss, who takes full credit. When her boss breaks her leg while on a ski trip, the secretary teams up with an investment broker in order to advance her career. However things grow complicated once her boss returns to the office. 

(This romantic comedy-drama was directed by Mike Nichols and stars Harrison Ford, Sigourney Weaver, and Melanie Griffith. It was nominated for six Academy Awards in 1989, including Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actress for Griffith, with both Weaver and Joan Cusack winning nominations for Best Supporting Actress. It also won four Golden Globe Awards that year, including Best Motion Picture/Musical or Comedy, Best Actress/Musical or Comedy for Griffith, and Best Supporting Actress for Weaver.)


(Demi Moore was linked to the project in its early stages, while Michelle Pfeiffer and Meryl Streep were considered for the roles eventually played by Griffith and Weaver, respectively. Brooke Shields fiercely lobbied to play Griffith's role and Diane Lane and Sara Jessica Parker were also in talks to play the part. Kathleen Turner, Cher, Geena Davis, Debra Winger, and especially Shelley Long were under consideration for Weaver's role. In her memoir, Lorraine Bracco recalled that she gave a first-rate audition for the role Griffith would win and was devastated when she was not chosen.)

(Though Griffith is unquestionably the lead character, she received third billing, after Harrison Ford and Sigourney Weaver. While Griffith had received critical acclaim for her performances in 1984's Body Double and 1986's Something Wild, those films didn't have much impact at the box office and her work remained largely unknown. 20th Century Fox wanted a big name to play the titular role, but Mike Nichols wanted only Griffith and dug in until the studio gave in.)

(Another casting issue occurred when Harrison Ford was cast as the investment banker. According to casting director Juliet Taylor, "Mike and I had already kind of fallen for Alec Baldwin and wanted him to play Jack, but the studio was catatonic about that. They did not want two unknowns in the leads." Producer Douglas Wick recalls "So, Mike had to call Alec and say, 'Look, I'm really sorry. The circumstances have changed. Would you do this other part?' Alec understood and was so lovely about it. He came in and really nailed that character. It was an awkward adjustment.")


(In subsequent interviews, Griffith has been straightforward about her struggles with drugs and alcohol during the making of this film. In one interview, she recalled how she and fellow actor Alec Baldwin were partying in Manhattan late one night, before showing up late and visibly intoxicated the next day.  Nichols and produce Wick were so upset, they decided to implement drastic measures, fining Griffith around $80,000 for the lost production time. They then employed a nurse on the set to test Griffith's sobriety for the remainder of the shoot.)

  ("There were a lot of things that happened on Working Girl that I did that were not right," Griffith recalled in 2019. "It was the late ‘80s. There was a lot going on party-wise in New York. There was a lot of cocaine. There was a lot of temptation. Mike got so mad at me, he wouldn't talk to me. Mike Haley, the first [assistant director], just came up and said, 'We're shutting down. Go home', and I knew I was in so much trouble. The next morning he took me to breakfast and said, 'Here's what's going to happen. You're going to pay for last night out of your pocket. We're not going to report you to the studio, but you have to pay for what it cost', and it was $80,000. They wanted to get my attention and they really did. It was a very humbling, embarrassing experience, but I learned a lot from it.")

(Three weeks after filming had been completed, Griffith entered the Hazelden Foundation, a rehab center in Minnesota. Ironically, according to a biographer Mark Harris, Nichols was battling a cocaine addiction of his own around that same time.)


 (In order to prepare for their roles, Weaver and Griffith followed several female executives and secretaries on their hectic daily schedules in New York City and sat in during meetings to get a better idea of how industry worked from a female perspective.)


(The film's lobby scenes were shot in the lobby of the World Trade Center, which was destroyed in the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001.)

--- ---

And that's all for now.

Tune in next week...

Same time, same channel!

Let The River Run - Carly Simon
from the motion picture Working Girl

Wednesday, February 22, 2023

Who Did It Better? State Of Independence

Who Did It Better?
State Of Independence

For today's edition of Who Did It Better? we have a song with a long and interesting history. It seems to be a song which artist's can't help but revisit more than once. For, not only does the first version get a second life when it's re-released as part of a Best Of collection, it is also re-recorded ten years later by the same vocalist backed by an orchestra. And that's not even the most popular version. 

The most popular version would also be given second life fourteen years after that vocalist originally recorded it, in the form of a remixed version which manages to eclipse the chart success of that vocalist's original recording. But wait... 

We then have yet another group who, with a guest vocalist, take the song on and release it not only on the group's album, but also as part of the OST of a very popular movie. In addition, it then appears six years later on the guest vocalist's regular group's greatest hits package. 

Confused?

Well, let's breakdown all this word salad for you, my dears, and take a look at the history of this rather remarkable song.

State of Independence is a song written by Jon Anderson, frequent lead singer for the prog-rock band Yes, and Vangelis, of Chariots Of Fire fame.

As Anderson recalls...

"I walked into the studio in Paris and he [Vangelis] was just putting that sequence down on 24 track. And most of the music we did was first take from the backing track point of view and the shape of things and I just told him to put the microphone on and he said, 'Cool.' And he was recording and he went to the piano and I started singing. And we recorded that track totally as it was and he would follow my emotion vocally and vice versa, if he went to a minor chord I'd come back down and sing in a different mode. That's why you have the highs and lows in working with Vangelis, because it is a very spontaneous combustion idea. That we're working as a team, not knowing where we're going. A couple of days later I started doing the lyrics and I went in and sang it and by then he'd done all the arranging and it was finished after two or three sessions. It was done, there it was."

"The concept of the song is the state of independence that we are growing into. And Oroladian was the sort of mythical person that opened the remembering gate. It's a poem by a famous English poet, The Remembering Gate. We start to remember our truth, we start to remember our reality. So each line is very, very positive. It's a worldwide collection of each line. It was the idea that it's easier to discern truth and life as a game. It's not as complicated as we make it in the West."

"The Caribbean sense of freedom derives from the meditative state. Meditation, something to do with the Caribbean, is African, very Ethiopian, essentially. The music from Ethiopia created reggae, calypso, all these kind of rhythms. Ska. It all comes from Ethiopia. I was really aware in my head about all that, so I was trying to do this worldwide oneness again, and that's what the song is about. State of Independence is all about how the truth will come."

The song first appeared on the 1981 Jon And Vangelis album The Friends of Mr Cairo, and was released as a single but failed to chart. Their version was re-released in 1984 as part of a Best Of album and then that version peaked at #67 in the UK.

Donna Summer, under the guidance of Quincy Jones, covered State of Independence for her 1982 self-titled album. As I mentioned in a previous post, this proved to be a difficult album for Summer. First, her record company, Geffen, rejected a completed album, I'm A Rainbow, which contained a number of self-penned songs. The powers that be felt it was uncommercial and encouraged her to work with Jones, instead. (I'm A Rainbow wouldn't see the light of day for another sixteen years.) Secondly, she was very, very pregnant at the time, making it difficult to sing her best. And to top things off, Summer found Jones to be boisterous, oppressive and demanding. Shortly after the album's release she told the Los Angeles Times: "Sometimes I feel it's a Quincy Jones album that I sang on."

Her version was released as the album's second single. For it, Quincy Jones had assembled an all-star choir, including Lionel Richie, Dionne Warwick, Michael Jackson, Brenda Russell, Christopher Cross, Dyan Cannon, James Ingram, Kenny Loggins, Peggy Lipton, Patti Austin, Michael McDonald and Stevie Wonder. (Jones later claimed that this song laid the foundation for the group effort We Are The World, which was written by Jackson and Richie, and produced by Jones.)

Summer's original version just missed the Top 40 in the US, peaking at #41. It did much better in Europe, where it peaked at #14 in the UK and enjoyed a one-week stay at #1 in the Netherlands. The single was reissued in Europe in 1990 following the release of a compilation album, The Best of Donna Summer. 

But that would not be the last time Summer's version would see the charts.

Following the dance chart success of the 1995 remix of  Summer's I Feel Love, PolyGram, who now owned all of Summer's recordings, issued a remixed version of State of Independence. In 1996, it peaked at #13. in the UK. Plus, it proved, once again, to be a huge hit in the Netherlands, where it remained #1 for eight weeks in a row.

In 1992, the duo Moodswings included a version of the song on their album Moodfood. Retitled Spiritual High (State Of Independence) Pt. II, their version featured vocals by the Pretenders' lead singer, Chrissie Hynde. It would also contain samples from Martin Luther King's 1963 speech, I Have A Dream. The single peaked at #47 in the UK and was played during the closing credits on the soundtrack of the 1992 film, Single White Female. It was also included on the Pretenders' Greatest Hits collection released in 2000.

In 1994, Change We Must was the seventh solo album by Yes lead singer Jon Anderson. It contained new material and orchestral arrangements of songs from Anderson's past. He recorded a new version of State Of Independence which was released as a double A-side single with the album's title song in October of 1994. 

And that's the whole story.

Now? On to the competition!

The Song: State Of Independence

The Competitors: Jon And Vangelis vs. Summer vs. Moodswings Feat. Chrissie Hynde vs. Anderson

State Of Independence - Jon And Vangelis

State Of Independence - Donna Summer

Spiritual Hight (State Of Independence) Pt. II - Moodswings 
feat. Chrissie Hynde

State Of Independence - Jon Anderson

Jon And Vangelis

Messy jazz intro yields to thin-sounding synth loop yields to vaguely reggae keyboard.

Lots going on with that those treble keys - it's all off-balance, or is it? The vocal cadence just messes with things even more, and boy, are those vocals pitched high.

Fun little horn accents and electronic blurps and a psuedo-flutelike afterthought. This is fun stuff. Complicated. If broken down instrument line by instrument line, it probably does make sense and is rather simplistic, but piled on top of one another my ear gets pulled in so many directions it's like walking down the hallway in a funky haunted house with various things jumping out at you as you pass by.

Sadly, due to the pitch of the vocals, I'm getting only the vaguest sense of what he's about.

The whole song seems to sweep by. I admire the technological achievement, but not the musicality. I think its the vocals. No depth. No warmth. As shrill as that bleating sax. 

The 'beep-beep' instrumental section is rather fun. And anytime that rhythmic, pulsing synth loop looms up I reengage. 

Vocals are much better on that mellower C-section.

And the chorus of auto horns are super fun. This is a song that's been constructed, not written. Rather adore that languid urban stretch. 

Still have no idea what he's singing about. Maybe its more about a feeling or creating a sound mood than the actual lyrical content.

By the time we peak with the song's title, things seem rather glommed together. I appreciate the artistry. It feels vaguely experimental and raw. I bet Bjork wet herself when she first heard this. It's very noisy. 

Like the chug of the rhythm track as we move to the close at the 3:40 mark. Thing is, the song is sonically a bit like an active seismic fault line, continuing to shift unpredictably and unexpectently.  It's also constantly revealing itself, opening like a multi-layered flower. 

It takes me all the way until the 3:48 mark before I start to really feel the deepness of the groove. I can tell, because that's when the head nodding starts. Love those automobiles racing by. 

And then... and odd ending with that overly-pointed sax.

Fascinating song. 

Donna Summer

Love that faked-out synth bass and Giorgio Moroder loop. The hand claps. This is already more accessible. Warmer. 

Summer sounds even better than I remember. Very centered. Nice depth. And yes, they're wisely keeping the arrangement much more focused, creating a pop song rather than a soundscape. That also helps with the momentum of the piece. I feel it being propelled forward. 

That choir is awesome. Again, great depth. 

And yet, we get all those weird, rhythmic elements floating in and out. It's simply so much cleaner. 

I'm starting to think these lyrics are really silly.

Interesting use of the choir with the sax. Oh, that's the what I call the 'beep beep' section. No, I don't know what they're singing. Is it 'deet'?

The vibraphone with those lovely synth strings... nice passage. 

Huh. I think Summer is doing a wonderful job on the C-section, but the bass and what-not are competing with her too much, rather than supporting. Those vocals need a bed to lie on, not a percolator.  But then, immediately after, with 'the temple of your heart', Summer fixes everything. She sounds amazing. Those notes are in her honey range. Money in the bank. 

And she just keeps bringing the love until that choir takes over. And then she's back in focus until those giant swaths of synth washes move across the soundscape like clouds across the bluest sky. And the chaos that descends is fascinating. Such a war of sound. Slow fade into a spoken word bit, which escapes me. 

Another marvelous experiment. 

Moodswings Feat. Chrissie Hynde

Spacey intro and it takes a bit before Hynde's vocals come into focus. Hynde singing languidly like this is what I imagine being on heroin feels like. 

A bit pitchy with those 'oh's. And the trapset up in the mix sort of starts to bring things even more into focus. Those vocals are super saturated, but nicely treated. And this arrangement reveals the era which it is from starting at the 1:28 mark. That weird organ grind underneath. 

Oh, Hynde pops things up an octave and actually lands it. She sounds good up there - treated as all get out, but spacey fun. Then the hard attack with the song's title... unexpected. 

Where did they get that choir? Did they sample? Hmm. 

And Hynde, again, surprises, going full-throated and flexing out on that C-section. It's weird, I've never considered her a soulful singer... but, here she is, pulling it off. 

I do love how the arrangement never competes. It only supports and creates atmosphere. The focus is totally on Hynde and her vocals. 

Love the little acoustic piano accent. 

At the 3:26 mark that choir takes over... meh. I keep waiting for Hynde to pop back in. Weird howling wind sound - spooky. 

I can't remember what that rhythm was called. It was everywhere... Soul II Soul perfected it. It has a shake and a shuffle to it that I adore. Was it part of the New Jack Swing sound? 

Okay, they sort of lose focus once that choir takes over. Hynde does reappear, but as a ghost. And it just fades.  A little disappointing. 

Jon Anderson

This is Anderson with a full orchestra.

Love the intro, though I feel I am about to watch a news panel show on PBS.  In fact... is that the case? Do they use this for the intro to something?

Oh, I don't know if I have the patience for this. It feels a bit overheated, like a piece of musical theatre. 

I think Anderson's vocals are an acquired taste. I always liked him when he sang with Yes. Their stuff, at times, just as pompous as this. 

Oh, dear. A children's choir. And that string arrangement is all over the place. Talk about trying to fill space. All the vamps make me feel like I'm trapped in a theatre about to be forced to sit through a musical.

I suppose there is an audience for this. It's not me. This is for those who appreciate what became of Manheim Steamroller or that hacky Siberian Orchestra. Yes, sonically, very accomplished and grand, but... a steady diet of such? A form of musical obesity. 

And what a ham-fisted ending. 

Well. That was dramatic, huh?

The Verdict

Going with Summer's version. 

Loved all the experimental constructivism of the Vangelis version. What a magnificent soundscape. A marvelous experiment. But, Anderson's vocals are a tad shrill and annoying and I have no idea what he's going on about. It makes me want Bjork to take this on and destroy it.

Summer brings the warmth and depth. And though I'm not a big fan of Quincy Jones' approach to the piece - Summer does indeed come across as more of a featured vocalist than the star of the show - he keeps things simple enough that the average listener can digest his arrangement while finding the groove. It's really Summer's vocals, though, that keep the ship on course. And that all-star choir? Well. That's an amazing feat. And it pays off, for the most part. A bit of showboating, on Jones' part, but... well, that's what the man does.

Moodswing had so much right. The beginning is terribly unfocused, but once we get beyond it and Hynde takes center stage, then things click right along. Some interesting vocal arranging, lots of atmospherics, lovely support... but then the choir takes over and zzzzzz. Which is too bad, because Hynde really delivers throughout, constantly surprising. 

Anderson with that orchestra? Well. That's a paycheck earned and cased, now isn't it. Pompous, overwrought, and, well... dull. I just kept backing up the aisle hoping the doors weren't locked. 

So, it's Summer for me, which is how I sort of expected it to go. Time and again, I'm amazed by how warm and rich her vocals remain. There's a good reason why we've always loved her.

Oh... and did you know? Moodswings has a version with Hynde and snippets of Martin Luther King doing his I Have A Dream Speech that stretches out to over 15 minutes! Yes. Something else I'll never have the patience to sit through. But interesting, huh?  

--- ---

And that's enough of me.

Okay, your turn. You know what to do... leave your choice and thoughts in the comments section. I do enjoy hearing a differing opinion. 

And that's all for now.

Until next time...

Thanks for reading... and listening!

State Of Independence - Donna Summer

Spiritual Hight (State Of Independence) Pt. II - Moodswings 
feat. Chrissie Hynde

State Of Independence - Donna Summer
(Murk Club Mix)